Working Interview
- Started
- Last post
- 54 Responses
- 20020
Basically, this is a design exercise.
- ernexbcn0
Don't work for free disguised as "test".
- usually its a generic exercise that is not tied to a client2002
- if that's the case I guess it's ok, but you are still investing time on it...ernexbcn
- yeah its shit but they are also investing time to interview the candidate2002
- in Spain lots of companies do these "tests" with real work, fucking assholesernexbcn
- thats bs and you get bs work2002
- 20020
Problem with design exercises:
- you are not 100% devoted to it and result is not always ideal
- they want exact or better execution against your portfolio
- working in isolation with out proper feedback and brief leads to off the mark execution
- they have an execution in mind but wont tell and will deduct points when you are off
- when you hire someone, you hire for their potential and not their current ability
- 20020
I once saw a design exercise which the designer hired another designer to do. The hired designer later applied for the same job and showed it as a portfolio piece.
- hektor9110
Honestly I've been never asked to do something like this. One would think that after a detailed explanation of your portfolio pieces, the strategy and thought behind the work during the interview where everybody has the opportunity to question anything related to the work or share vital information regarding the position to be filled will be enough.
I have enough experience to spot bull-shit, but in this case everything has been different I think tomorrow will be the decisive day after the meeting/brief.
- doesnotexist0
if they have any respect for you, they'd pay you for your time. if you had any respect for yourself, you would tell them you need to be paid.
- really depends on who has the upper hand or more ego.2002
- not really. at all. it's called integrity.doesnotexist
- usually that doesnt last long when you are hungry2002
- You're both correct.OSFA
- but you are wrong2002
- freedom0
I've done it and gotten paid.
- kona0
I walk into restaurants all the time and say "listen, this will be sort of a working interview. I'm going to eat a steak for free so I can get a feel if we would be a good fit together, for future dinning experiences I may have, if this turns out to be a good steak."
I am currently banned from eating in Illinois.
- will you be hiring the restaurant for full time?2002
- It didn't work out. I didn't tell them how I wanted the steak cooked. I like medium-rare. He gave me medium-well.kona
- so you are looking to hire a restaurant full time for all your meals?2002
- Shame... they could've gotten a ton of exposure...OSFA
- If they thought they might get 80k a year from you, they might give you a free steak.freedom
- 20020
when you are selecting a wedding cake or catering, some places charge for sampling and others dont.
- OSFA0
So, this is happening tomorrow?
- 20020
should we play - Lets Guess the Agency?
- OSFA0
- freedom0
Some of you need to get over yourselves.
He's only applying for Senior Designer. If he likes the agency and wants the job, it's probably worth investing a few days as a trial. He should be paid, but the reward is greater than 2 days pay.
- so when do you start given yourself respect?doesnotexist
- after you've sacrificed yourself?doesnotexist
- christ man, remind me never to hire you for any work2002
- no more nude modeling2002
- OSFA0
"Some of you need to get over yourselves... He's only applying for Senior Designer."
- whatthefunk0
Do you possess significant financial industry experience, I've seen a lot of financial institutions struggling to find designers.
I had a place ask me to come in for a day, paid, and then after that day they asked me to work on a project, paid. After the day in the office I decided that it wasn't a great cultural fit and passed on the role. Remember, these are two way streets and perhaps this is a great opportunity to realize what their culture is like.
- btw did you get out of design?2002
- Nope, I'm a UX Manager now. Product focused no production...great transition...whatthefunk
- hektor9110
oh wow easy there people. @OSFA yes this is ONLY a Senior Designer position, next time I'll make it worth your while and ask about a ECD or ABC or LSD who the f$%& cares.
- capn_ron0
How did it go hektor?
- 20020
bump